Why fiction has to make sense but real live doesn’t.
Don’t you sometimes wish in our writing we could just
toss in completely illogical things?
I use the Cinderella quote to show you an example of a
time fiction did NOT make any sense.
Cinderella is being watched over by her
Fairy Godmother who is...not that observant, apparently. Why oh why did she
stand by invisibly all those years when Cinderella was being mistreated? Why
did she finally snap to when there was a pretty dress needed?
Maybe she’s not all that powerful. After all the coach
turned back into a pumpkin after a few hours. (I wonder why the shoe didn’t
vanish. Hmmm….)
Maybe the Fairy Godmother is all knowing and bides her
time and steps in when there was a
prince to lasso?
Maybe that cat driving vermin (I HATE MICE) out of the
castle is somehow the bad guy. I’m sure he’s just cranky because Cinderella is
protecting the stupid mice. It is perfectly reasonable for the cat to kill them. This is NOT villainous behavior, people! (hard not
to root for the cat here!)
Whatever it is, it makes no sense. And, other than
classic fairy tales, our books need to make sense.
Examples I think of where fiction did NOT make sense…I
remember this scene. I think it was from live action George of the Jungle.
There was a narrator talking now and then and once he says, “All movies need a
really big coincidence and here’s ours.”
We do that, we have coincidences…and we have LEAPS, a
crime solver makes some connection between a clue and the criminal and I arch
my brow and wonder how he got THERE?
And also, as it pertains to Christian fiction, we can’t
have miracles. I’ve worked for seven or eight different publishers mow and did
you know they don’t like you to put miracles in your books?
That’s frustrating because a miracle can get you out of a
tight spot, but I understand and respect why it's a no no. Mostly we don’t get flat out
miracles in our daily lives. Mostly fire goes ahead and burns you. Lions go
ahead and eat you. Poisonous snakes bite you and you go ahead and die.
To solve your problems with miracles disrespects their true power and also it weakens your own
plot because working through the problems is the point of fiction, creating a
mess and then cleaning it up, usually with the maximum amount of pain is the
whole point of the exercise.
I’ve had a few miracles in my books but my main miracle
is the still small voice of God. No finger carving words into a stone, no
voice like thunder coming out of a boiling cloud, no burning bush. It’s people who pray and actually listen
to that quiet voice and is open to the Lord enough to act on it, even when it’s as quiet as an idea.
And we all know there IS NO GREATER MIRACLE than God forgiving and saving the eternal soul of a sinner.
And we all know there IS NO GREATER MIRACLE than God forgiving and saving the eternal soul of a sinner.
What about you? Do you have miracles in your books. I
love intervention from God in a book in those quiet voices, but what about
miracles? What about ‘convenient’ things that fall right into place at the right time.
Do you like that? Or do you wish you’d get a Fairy
Godmother who’d be a little more pro-active?
Leave a comment to get your name in the drawing for a
signed copy of No Way Up.
I got nuthin' on Sleeping Beauty. Do you realize she pretty much SLEPT through the whole movie? The scenes, the little clips of her singing, that's it. She's not on anymore than that.
And NO I’m not starting a series on Disney Princesses. I’ve
just had a couple of ideas.








