Seekerville’s resident poet, philosopher, romance devotee
and writer, Vince Mooney, has called my prose crystal clear. I didn’t pay Vince
to say this so naturally I appreciated the compliment. Vince and I have talked
about the topic. He compared crystal clear prose to a lake so crystal clear we
can see the bottom. In today’s world that’s rare.
Crystal clear makes me think of fine stemware. When you run a
damp finger around the rim of crystal, the glass will hum. Even sing. Good
stories sing. Clarity is one reason a story sings.
I’d considered writing a post about the subject long before
this, but I hesitated.
Why?
First, I’m not sure how to write with clarity so how can I teach
others? I decided the topic was important enough to try.
Second, what if my post is confusing and I look like an
idiot? I opted to take that risk. After all, this is Seekerville, a safe place
to share our thoughts.
Why should writers try for crystal clear prose? On the
flipside, what’s wrong with ambiguity?
· When readers must reread a sentence or passage to figure out what the author meant, they’re ripped out of the story.
· When readers must reread a sentence or passage to figure out what the author meant, they’re ripped out of the story.
·
When words and descriptions are vague or
farfetched, readers lose interest and set the book aside.
·
When our words don’t reveal a clear-cut point for
the scene, the stakes won’t rise for the reader.
We writers want to make sure our style is easily understood,
orderly and logical. How to achieve that clarity is harder to pin down. Here’s my
two cents.
·
WRITE EVERYTHING YOU WRITE WITH CLARITY. I’ve followed that advice for
years.
Write that email, note or memo with
clarity. Put your thoughts in sentence form. Write as if the reader is someone you
want to impress, like an editor or Grammar Queen. I’ve even learned the
importance of clarity on the grocery list since my retired husband does the
shopping. Rice doesn’t work, not when wild rice, converted rice, brown rice and
minute rice are on the shelves. When I’m not clear about what I want, I deserve
what I get. That applies to far more than grocery lists. But I digress.
I hear groaning. Do you think
writing everything with clarity is a waste of valuable time? Perhaps rereading
and, if necessary rewriting messages, will waste time at first. But, practice
makes perfect. When you make sure your words convey the meaning you intend, you
develop the habit of writing with clarity until crystal clear prose comes naturally.
·
WATCH THOSE LITTLE THINGS THAT CAN CONFUSE THE
READER. To learn more about revising for clarity, read here.
BEWARE OF IT. When undefined, IT can be vague and clutter up your prose.
Example: He entered the dark house.
It was scary.
What was scary? The house? The
dark? The sound of the creaking floorboards beneath his feet? Replace generic
“it” with rich details that illicit emotion and clarify events. When you can, rewrite sentences to
eliminate “it.” You will write tighter and with more clarity.
BEWARE OF PRONOUNS. Use names when pronouns
might confuse the reader. Or give the character an action that makes his
identity obvious. This is especially important when a character thinks about someone
of the same gender.
BEWARE OF DOUBLE WORDS. Double
words stop me every time. Example: Though he’d hurt her her heart would mend. Adding
a comma between the two hers helps. Or use her proper name. Though he’d hurt
her, Julie’s heart would mend. Or reword.
BEWARE OF USING WORDS FOR WORDS
SAKE. Long convoluted sentences bog a reader down. Straightforward words chosen
with care read smoothly. Simple, short sentences can carry a wallop. The reason
suspense writers use them.
BEWARE OF IMPROPER GRAMMAR AND
PUNCTUATION. A missing comma, a poorly constructed sentence, a dangling
participle can confuse.
·
GIVE CHARACTERS EXPLICIT GOALS, MOTIVATIONS AND
CONFLICTS. When those important story elements are absent or vague, readers won’t
connect with and root for the characters. Show and tell the reader what the
character wants early on.
·
WRITE SCENES THAT FORWARD THE PLOT. When we
write a scene without a point or without a character goal, the scene doesn’t advance
the plot or raise the stakes. Pointless tea scenes add nothing to the story and
leave the reader perplexed. Or scenes that take forever to get to the point slow
the pace.
·
DO YOUR RESEARCH. When writers don’t know what they’re
describing sometimes they try to cover a lack of research with vague descriptions
that confuse the reader or worse, leave her dissatisfied, even angry.
These suggestions for crystal clear prose range from word
choice to sentence structure to plot elements, even research. If that wide range is overwhelming
yet you want to work on clarity, tackle one.
If clarity is your strength, share your suggestions for crystal
clear prose.
I brought eggs, bacon and toasted bagels for breakfast. The eggs
are over easy, not scrambled. The bacon is straight and crisp, simple to handle.
The bagels are crunchy, easy to chew. Our menu is rich with clarity. LOL
Leave a comment for a chance to win a copy of The Bride Wore
Spurs. If you bought my novel, thank you from the bottom of my heart! Still,
why not put your name in the hat. If you win a second copy, you can share the
story with a friend.
Hi Janet,
ReplyDeleteI enjoyed reading The Bride Wore Spurs. And, no, I didn't buy it. You sent it to me. But I would have. :)
The coffee pot is set.
I'm sure we all try for clarity, but the tips are great helps.
Helen
I already read my emails like 3 times over!!!
ReplyDeleteI run a word search for "it" as part of the revision process and change out as close to 100% as if changing "it" would turn into a convoluted mess.
I am naturally very wordy, so I work hard at condensing, but I have a great CP whose main strength is to find when I use 20 words where I could have used 3. He's very handy that way. :)
The Bride Wore Spurs sounds like a great book. Please enter me in contest. Thank you for the opportunity to win.
ReplyDeleteI love this cover and loved this book! Which reminds me, I need to leave a review.
ReplyDeleteThis was a great review post. I should re-read this every time I sit down to write.
Hi Janet I understood what you said.
ReplyDeleteAs a reader one thing I struggle with is an author who has swallowed a dictionary! I read a book where the author was highly educated and used intellectual words I had no idea how to pronounce let alone understand. I found it very distracting and it made me feel dumb.
I have your book Thanks so much for sending it. Its on my TBR book. Now I am finally sleeping I am making up for lost time I tend to go to bed tired by 9pmish and and sleep. Hoping that soon I will be able to read again at night but I am happy just to know I am sleeping well. I did tend to wake occasionally but go back to sleep even been sleeping in, today it was almost 7am when I got up. I got over 9 hours sleep with only waking a few times and going back to sleep. This is so exciting after sleeping so little for 9 or so months.
Hi Janet,
ReplyDeleteWhat a great post. When I crit a piece for somebody, I always try to point out a sentence that takes more than twice to read. I agree that it's important to make things clear the first time to not frustrate or lose your reader.
I'd love to have my name tossed in the drawing.
Thanks for sharing today. Lots of good advice.
Good morning, Janet.
ReplyDeleteGreat post! My husband always accuses me of being unclear when I'm speaking because of overuse of pronouns. I'm careful with them when I'm writing, but when I get caught up telling a story, apparently I litter with pronouns.
Happy Monday.
Good morning, Helen! Thanks for the coffee, a must on what's a rainy morning here. I'm delighted you won and enjoyed The Bride Wore Spurs! A win-win for us both.
ReplyDeleteYes, we all try for clarity. My windows are in dire need of a different kind of clarity.
Janet
Melissa, fun to find another anal email writer. :-) Sometimes rereading saves me from foot in mouth, too. LOL
ReplyDeleteGood idea to search for "it." Though I can barely write the word. It is like a nail on a chalkboard for me.
Aren't CPs the greatest? They see what we don't.
Janet
Thanks for your interest in The Bride Wore Spurs, Emma. We appreciate readers!
ReplyDeleteJanet
Oh, Virginia, I'm so happy you loved The Bride Wore Spurs. If you have time, I'd love a review. Not sure how much reviews help sell books, but they are a lovely morale booster. Or not. :-) Depends on the review.
ReplyDeleteThanks for your kind comment about the post. I always hope my posts help writers.
Janet
Janet, I start editing my ms today. I so need this.
ReplyDeleteAnd like Mary Curry, my husband (and everyone else) gives me the deer-in-the-headlights looks, followed by a WHAT??? Don't know if it's what I say or that I talk too fast.
JENNY,using big words is a pet peeve of mine. One or so per page I can handle. But if I feel like the author is just trying to impress me w/her voluminous vocabulary or that she wore-out her thesaurus to use idiosyncratic words, I get annoyed.
Oh, and Janet, please throw my name into the hat. I'd love to win the Bride Wore Spurs.
ReplyDeleteGood morning, Jenny! I'm with you. When an author puts uses lots of words that make readers feel dumb, why would readers want to buy their books? By the way, the image you painted with your words--authors who swallowed a dictionary--is terrific writing.
ReplyDeleteI'm happy to hear you're sleeping well. The books can wait.
Janet
Hi Jackie,
ReplyDeleteYou make a great point. Often we writers know what we're trying to say so we don't see the lack of clarity.
Thanks for your interest in The Bride Wore Spurs!
Janet
Hi Mary Curry! Not sure pronouns are the culprit when my dh doesn't understand what I'm saying. I was hoping he wasn't a good listener so the fault was his. :-)
ReplyDeleteJanet
Clarity is not my strength. I'm clear as mud most days. :-) The her hers and he hes get me all the time. I thought I was being clever by give my hero a female dog. That way it's all he/she and no confusion...until he hooks up with the heroine. Oy. I just wrote a riveting scene with the heroine and the dog. I was very proud of myself until I read it over and discovered it read as if the heroine was howling and the dog was sipping tea. Oy. Oy.
ReplyDeleteNo need to enter me in the draw Janet, I loved The Bride Wore Spurs!
Good morning, Connie! I've had that reaction too. I wonder if we're trying to speak fast before our friends and family stop listening. LOL I find I can't interpret others words as quickly as I once could so maybe others are struggling with the same. I'm trying to slow down when I speak.
ReplyDeleteJanet
Thanks for your interest in my book, Connie! Your name is in the hat.
ReplyDeleteJanet
Oh, Kav! Spew alert!!! Helen's coffee is all over my keyboard! LOL Thank goodness for second chances--commonly known as revisions--so your dog will howl and your heroine is sipping tea.
ReplyDeleteYour sweet words about my book have blessed me. Thank you!
Janet
Janet, can you post next about a crystal clear mind?
ReplyDeleteI'm sort of foggy here lately.
Wonderful advice! Timely since I think readers are less tolerant of purple prose - the long, flowery descriptions. (It's fun to pull out some of my favorite books with publishing dates from the late 70's and 80's)
ReplyDeleteWow, another great post! Seekerville is like attending a mini-workshop each morning.
ReplyDeleteClarity is something I've been wrestling with. That worrisome 'it' sneaks into my writing. I know what 'it' is, so I expect my reader to know too. Not fair.
My writing is so much better than it was, and after this timely post I know it'll get even better.
Thanks Janet, glad you went ahead and put in your 'copper'!
Mary Hicks
Janet,
ReplyDeleteClarity is an issue of mine, so I appreciate your list of "crystal clear" suggestions. I have your book and loved it so someone else's name can be pulled out of the---what do you use cat dish, Mason jar or Stetson?
Piper
I love this, Janet! This post will certainly go into my Seekerville notebook. I'm all for expanding my vocabulary, but I'm with Jenny, not while I'm reading.
ReplyDeleteLOL, Mary! Blame that fogginess on your rich inner life. Or allergies. Whatever works better for you!
ReplyDeleteJanet
Good morning, Sherrie! So true! What once worked no longer does. We need to be chamelions, able to change our writing styles with the times. Today's readers want fast paced, quick reads. Makes me wonder what stories will look like in the future. Maybe they'll be scanned into readers heads.
ReplyDeleteJanet
Hi Mary Hicks! Thanks for your praise for Seekerville! I totally agree. Everyday I learn something new. Sometimes something said in a comment.
ReplyDeleteI've seen in my own writing that when I identify a problem I'm well on the way to resolving the issue. Isn't it encouraging to see that improvement? Proud of you!!
Janet
Hi Piper! Thanks! Ruthy uses the cat dish. I'm pet allergic so usually put names in a wide brimmed Victorian hat. But the Stetson works far better for The Bride Wore Spurs! I'm so glad you enjoyed my first western setting!
ReplyDeleteJanet
Hi Jill! My Seekerville notebook is covered with doodles and filled with reams of writing tips. I tend to like hard copy, but then can't find what I need. LOL The archives are easier to access.
ReplyDeleteJanet
Janet, I loved The Bride Wore Spurs. No need to enter me in the contest.
ReplyDelete"It" is a pet peeve word of mine as a reader and a writer. Like Melissa I search and replace most if not all.
Another vague phrase that drives the reader in me up the wall..."the task at hand." Mostly thought by female characters when she is daydreaming about the hero and then turns her attention back to the task at hand.
What is the task at hand?
The world may never know.
Hi Janet, I'm glad you went with this topic. When I read a book that uses interesting, specific details and clear prose, I know the author has done her research and it inspires me to tighten my own writing.
ReplyDeleteI have The Bride Wore Spurs and am half way through! I'm really enjoying it. :) Catchy title, btw.
JANET!!! THIS IS FLAT-OUT OUTSTANDING!! What a GREAT post with absolutely GREAT nuggets for every writer and everything we write -- from those novels to that confounded grocery list.
ReplyDeleteYou said, "I’ve even learned the importance of clarity on the grocery list since my retired husband does the shopping. Rice doesn’t work, not when wild rice, converted rice, brown rice and minute rice are on the shelves."
OH. MY. GOODNESS!!! This could be in the Bible, it's SO true!! When I used to send my daughter to the grocery store, all I would have to do is say the item and she KNEW what brand, size, etc. to get me.
My husband??? Uh, not so much. In fact, not at all. :| For him, I have to spell out size, color, brand, flavor and consistency along with color of the package and exact wording. For my Walmart list, I actually tape the type of bobby pins, paper clips, and package labels on the list itself to make sure he gets the right product and even then, it's iffy.
BUT ... I am NOT complaining (at least not to him), since I am BEYOND grateful that he runs these errands for me, which I HATE!!
THIS is definitely a keeper, Janet -- GREAT JOB and GREAT writing!!
Hugs,
Julie
Great post JANET. Crystal clear. Yep, you made it clear all right. That is exactly why you need editors and crit partners. In my head the scene is clear, but then I discover I didn't get what was in my head on the paper.
ReplyDeleteGood points.
Loved The Bride Wore Spurs. CLEARLY a terrific romance. smile
Yep, clarity. I am thinking about the last time I gave directions to Man O. Epic fail.
ReplyDeleteThanks for the suggestions to help me on foggy Mondays like this one.
Loved the book! No need to put me in.
Peace, Julie
Oh yes, So related to the list for hubby. JULIE and JANET, I een have to put the color of the label. lol
ReplyDeleteHi Bridgett. I'm delighted you enjoyed The Bride Wore Spurs. I hope Hannah didn't turn to the task at hand. LOL
ReplyDeleteSeriously over use of anything irks readers. I've been guilty of too many lurching stomachs, locked gazes and lumps in the throat. Writers need fresh eyes to see what we're overdoing.
Janet
Hi Karen! Good to see you this morning! I enjoyed your April LIH, His Mountain Miss. Fun to see how two people from very different worlds find happiness.
ReplyDeleteI suggested the title to my editor, along with a dozen other possibilities, but one of the Seekers thought of it. Brainstorming titles with the Seekers is hilarious.
Janet
Well this one's a winner! No wonder they chose it. Titles are hard for me to think up. You're lucky to have a creative group of ladies to help. :) Thanks for the kind words about His Mountain Miss!
DeleteJulie, I'm giggling at your enthusiasm. Obviously like me, you've had your share of grocery list blunders. Aren't you clever to attach an example of what you want to the list? Carried to the extreme that list could get your dh arrested for shoplifting. LOL But like you, I'm grateful my dh handles that chore. I wonder how well we'd do at the hardware store? LOL
ReplyDeleteJanet
Good morning, Sandra! If only our brains could spill onto the page and bypass our fingers. A new medical procedure for writers--finger bypass. :-) At least we can write a terrific grocery list. Thanks to our husbands.
ReplyDeleteThanks for your sweet words for The Bride Wore Spurs!
Janet
Hi peaceful Julie! Directions? Now there's another topic. Like a terrific hook, epic fail makes me want to know more.
ReplyDeleteSo glad you enjoyed the book!
Janet
Hi Janet,
ReplyDeleteGreat post. Something I don't think of consciously but hopefully do anyway.
The part about the clarity of the character's goal and a purpose for the scene got my attention. Need to do that more.
Thanks for the tips. And loved your book, btw. Still have it so no need to add me to the draw. I will share my copy eventually!
Cheers,
Sue
LOL ... Hardware store??? Sorry, but that would drive me nuts ... and bolts!! :)
ReplyDeleteI thought of a writing pet peeve of mine that goes hand-in-hand with clarity. It drives me absolutely CRAZY when the author doesn't clearly describe or at least hint at the looks, personality of a character RIGHT AWAY (within the first page is great, but within the first chapter is a MUST). I'm one of those visual types who HAS to see the character in my mind, so I constantly flip to the cover when I'm reading a book to see what a particular expression from a scene might look like on the character's face. Sometimes I find myself rifling through pages just to find a description when one isn't given or it's buried somewhere.
Also, you said, "When I’m not clear about what I want, I deserve what I get."
LOL ... that's my husband's pat answer when he gets me the wrong thing. ;)
Great post!!
Hugs,
Julie
Janet - I am not finished reading yet but I love The Bride Wore Spurs. Thanks so much for writing it and writing it with fabulous clarity!
ReplyDeleteGreat post - if only I could follow your advice with more clarity:) my problem (more so than "it") is the "he" and "she" thing. But I', working on it.
Thanks so much, Cindy
Great post, Janet!
ReplyDeleteI was just polishing my first three chapters (again) last night and had to read a sentence twice. I figure if I have to read it twice, it needs rewriting!
And I'm learning a lot from the comments this morning, also. So when my husband retires, he becomes my assistant? Running errands, etc.? That sounds good to me!
The Bride Wore Spurs is on my TBR pile, but I'd love another copy for my church library :)
Great post, Janet! Clarity is why I have my hubby read my "almost-final" draft before I do final revisions. He will tell me if he finds anything confusing.
ReplyDeleteAnd believe me, I know how easy it is to confuse him with a grocery list! Blueberries--frozen, dried, or fresh? Green tea--decaf or regular; plain or Earl Grey Green? Couscous--regular or whole grain? Ground turkey--lean, or very lean?
I could go on . . . and on and on. Suffice it to say I have learned to spell out my shopping list requests in CLEAR and explicit detail!
I totally agree with you! Little things that can be confusing are distracting and pull me out of the story briefly. Clarity is a wonderful attribute!
ReplyDeleteThanks for a great post, and looking forward to reading your new book!
colorvibrant[at]gmail[dot]com
Wonderful tips, Janet (though your books are still better).
ReplyDeleteI have a real problem with the pronoun issue and I struggle to make sure, using action, that people know who's talking.
Love the comment about "IT," though I did have flashes of Monty Python jokes running through my head as I read it.
Janet, dear, such a sweetheart for encouraging writers to try to impress me.
ReplyDeleteSome of you need to try a little harder.
YOU KNOW WHO YOU ARE!!!
Excellent post, Janet! I'll be watching my writing for those clarity points. Your ideas will help me when I critique someone else, as well. I just bought The Bride Wore Spurs and will enjoy your "crystal clear" western. Thank you for sharing your "two cents" which were worth far more than two pennies! :)
ReplyDeleteThank you Janet---excellent post for my Keeper File (in fact, I have a feeling I'll be re-reading this very often for important reminders).
ReplyDeleteI won your book a while back, and LOVE it (and yes, if I hadn't won it, I'd certainly have purchased it--you are one of my fave LIH authors!).
Hugs from Georgia, Patti Jo :)
Janet, great post.
ReplyDeleteWaving to The Grammar Queen. Nice to see you, your majesty!
Must have a heart-to-heart talk with hubby over lunch about husbands who grocery shop. Oh my goodness. How lucky you ladies are! Not that my hubby isn't wonderful. He is. But he doesn't shop for groceries. Period!
So, Jan, it's not necessarily a given about hubby helping once he retires. I thought mine would take over the housework. I'm still laughing at my foolishness.
Trying to be clear...
Hope I made my point about hubby and shopping. :)
Hi Janet! This is a fabulous post--I love when I get simple, yet vital gems of writing advice. And this is just the kind of thing a novice writer like me needs. I'd love to be entered to win!
ReplyDeletehistoricalchristianreview(at)gmail(dot)com
Thank you and God bless!!
Hi Sue! I understand. I can't count the number of tea scenes I've written before I finally learned to give the character a scene goal right off the bat. I'm frustrated when I know better but catch myself making the same mistake.
ReplyDeleteGlad you enjoyed The Bride Wore Spurs!
Janet
Reading this makes me see Vince's point about the cleanness and clarity of your writing, Janet! Crisp, clear, clean and concise.
ReplyDeleteWhat a great lesson in looking at each word, thinking how phrases and sentences sound. Lovely, Janet-O!!!!
Cookies here today: M&M/Chocolate chip to welcome summer!!!!
I've finished edits on one book... editing first 2/3 of wip before I move into the last third of the book, making sure things are solid... so Janet this is the perfect time to refresh my mind on/with your excellent advice. Thank you!
GQ is here?????
ReplyDeleteShe sensed my disobedience to all things grammar and punctuative.
I'm DOOMED!!!
Julie, you're a hoot! I'm smiling at your comment: Hardware store??? Sorry, but that would drive me nuts ... and bolts!! :)
ReplyDeleteThanks for sharing another pet peeve. Writers should describe the character's appearance and personality early on. If we hope for readers to see our story as if they're watching a movie, we need to describe each character that comes onstage if only with a phrase or line.
Janet
Afternoon Cindy R! I'm thrilled that you're reading The Bride Wore Spurs. Thanks!
ReplyDeleteAwareness is key. Before long those pronouns will no longer trip you up.
Janet
Hi Jan! I can't promise your dh will become your assistant. Not all men are. I'm guessing yours will look for ways to give you more time to write once he's retired. If not, remind him how much a personal shopper costs. LOL
ReplyDeleteHmm, supportive spouses would make a good post.
Janet
Janet, I love this post. I tend to be so literal I share too much detail. :) I'm working on that balance between RUE, too many deets and not being so vague that readers end up confused.
ReplyDeleteI loved your thoughts on "It." I hadn't thought about how confusing this word can be. :)
Also, before I write a scene I think through how it will move the story forward, what the character's goals are and what the obstacles are.
Thanks for the excellent tips on clarity!
Hi Myra, Just proves the importance of details. In our stories and on the grocery lists!
ReplyDeleteJanet
Hi Heidi!
ReplyDeleteWonder what's harder for a writer to see? The little things or the big picture stuff? I can overlook something important, forest size while I'm focusing on the trees.
Anyone else care to weigh in with an opinion?
Janet
Afternoon Walt! Thanks!
ReplyDeleteAction tags are great ways to keep the characters straight. Excellent!
I avoid Monty. LOL Are his jokes shareable? If so, I'd love to see what he had to say about IT. I think.
Janet
Your Grace, I'm delighted you dropped in! Especially since you didn't call me out for bad grammar. :-) Really, who wouldn't want to impress you, Grammar Queen?
ReplyDeleteJanet
Let's see if I can write a clear, concise comment without imploding.
ReplyDeleteJanet, thanks for the checklist. My two beta readers just returned a section of my story with "huh??" marking the same two paragraphs. Thankfully, the "huh??" doesn't happen nearly as often as it used to. (Rats, there's an it.)
My characters don't drink a lot of tea, but they do tend to walk too much.
And now I must recuperate from writing so many complete sentences.
Nancy C
P.S. I've almost finished a Ruthy book. A Missy and a Debby are in my Seeker To-Read stack, but a Janet book would be nice to add :-)
ReplyDeleteNancy C
Hi Sherrida! You're sweet! Thanks bunches!
ReplyDeleteSpeaking of two cents, I learned an interesting fact about pennies recently. Will add a trivia question in a comment.
Janet
Hi Patti Jo, With all the fabulous LIH authors I love to read, you have made my day! Thank you!
ReplyDeleteHugs from Indiana. Janet
Debby, it just takes proper training.
ReplyDeleteLike, hubby says: "Dear, what's for supper?"
You: "Whatever you fix, honey. Call me when it's ready. I'm on deadline."
Hubby: "Hey, sweetheart, I just wore my last pair of clean underwear."
You: "Oh, really? The washing machine instructions are in the filing cabinet. Help yourself. I'm on deadline."
Hubby: "Darling, we're out of my favorite chips & dip."
You: "The car keys are on the counter. Do you need directions to the grocery store?"
Whoa, Debby, maybe you should keep the conversation general and avoid mentioning names. LOL
ReplyDeleteI'd hate to think what we'd eat when I'm on deadline if my dh didn't shop. I'm guessing peanut butter, canned veggies and soup.
Though I suppose someone here prepares and freezes food ahead and will make me look worse than I already do.
Janet
Good afternoon, Amber. Thanks for your encouraging words! Seekerville is a great spot for learning craft. I'm guessing with all the posts in the archives, you won't be a novice long.
ReplyDeleteJanet
Wow, Ruthy's playing nice. ;-) Just kidding. I marvel at your work ethic. You edit and manage to squeeze in time for homemade cookies warm from the oven! Yummy!
ReplyDeleteJanet
Clarity is not my strength. Eating is.
ReplyDeleteI do have much hidden talent. I bring you large whole strawberries stuffed with cream cheese and sprinkled with shaved chocolate.
Just what the Clarity Dr. ordered.
Hi Jeanne T! You make a fabulous point! Detail is vital...if it's important. How's that for clarity? LOL Seriously, showing our character doing a host of meaningless actions is boring. I've heard this called Walking the Dog. We need enough details to ground the reader but those details work best when they reveal what the character is feeling. This is a simplistic example, but let's say the heroine notices her hem is unraveling then realizes that's exactly what her life is doing, you've shown her with details.
ReplyDeleteJanet
Hi Nancy C,
ReplyDeleteDon't you love receiving verification that your writing is stronger? Congrats! I'm relieved your head didn't implode on my watch! LOL But you're so right. Making each word count is hard work. Just think, we're building brain muscles.
Janet
Myra, you have shown Goal and Motivation in a nutshell. So does this scenario carry any conflict? LOL You are a natural to write the post on dh support of writing wives.
ReplyDeleteJanet
Hi Janet,
ReplyDeleteGreat post, and very timely! I think clarity is one of my stronger points, which probably stems from being a journalist for seven years! Tight writing, to the point, no guess work on the part of the reader- that's what I wrote for years. A lot of that has spilled over into my fiction writing, to the point that I remind myself sometimes to add in those rich details, those nice descriptions, the things that make the reader not just like a book but LOVE it.
I hope I can find that balance.
Have a great day!
Janet noticed I'm nice today!!!
ReplyDeleteOh happy day!
:)
I was nice last week, too. I believe it was Tuesday because I've developed a New York State of Mind for Tuesdays... with Scenes from an Italian Restaurant.
Where or where is Vince?????
Billy Joel and I are heading back to Allentown, big guy. Help the displaced miners.
Janet is shaking her head, but I brought cookies so she'll forgive me!
Tina, these are fabulous. Do you pipe the cream cheese in? Cut those luscious strawberries in half first? I'll arm wrestle you for the last one on the plate!
ReplyDeleteJanet
Excellent post, Janet! This is something I'm still learning to do. I need constant reminders!
ReplyDeleteBTW, I am the queen of "It." I love the word.
ReplyDeleteGood afternoon, Stephanie. Your comment is crystal clear. Journalism gives you an edge for writing with clarity. Since journalists are to report the facts, not color opinion, does being a journalist make writing with emotion harder?
ReplyDeleteJanet
Ruthy, I'll admit I'm a tad confused, but that could just be me. :-)
ReplyDeleteBut, I did understand your question about Vince. I need to let him know I'm talking about him. Surely that will bring him by.
Janet
Great tips, Janet. I know one thing I struggle with as a reader is when an author uses complex vocabulary...almost like they're trying to amp it up by overusing the thesaurus. I love my thesaurus when I'm writing just to throw some variety in there, but I try not to use words that I have rarely...or never...heard of. Is there a general rule about using the thesaurus/variety of vocabulary when writing? I'd love to be in the drawing! : )
ReplyDeleteThanks and God bless~Stacey
travelingstacey(at)bellsouth(dot)net
Laughing Missy, Queen of It. Comparing that to Grammar Queen. We know what she's about. Sorry. Couldn't resist. Here's the last stuffed strawberry I was saving.
ReplyDeleteJanet
We had our talk. Hubby reminded me that he supports my writing in many other ways, which he does. :)
ReplyDeleteI agree with Vince, Janet. Your writing is crystal clear, which I love. A strength we should all work to enhance in our own writing.
I have my church writing group this evening, and I'm preparing my class topic. I'll mention your blog and the importance of clear writing.
Hi Stacey! I don't know a general rule for using a Thesaurus. Writers should vary the vocabulary but not toss in lots of big words to impress. One general rule is with dialogue tags. Said is good. Too many variations of said sound pretentious.
ReplyDeleteJanet
Debby, glad the lunchtime conversation went well. Don't want to risk indigestion. Knew your dh supports you!
ReplyDeleteThanks for your sweet words and mentioning the post to your church writers group. Do you take turns or are you the main teacher?
Janet
I'M PUTTING THIS IN CAPS TO BRING ATTENTION TO THIS TRIVIA QUESTION. I LEARNED RECENTLY THAT THE PENNY WAS MADE OF STEEL. THE COIN WAS CALLED A SILVER PENNY. ANYONE CARE TO GUESS WITHOUT LOOKING ONLINE WHAT YEAR THE SILVER PENNY WAS ISSUED?
ReplyDeleteJANET
Janet, here you go. It's from Monty Python's "The Holy Grail." It's a 5-min-plus clip and you have to go to about 4:40 into the clip to hear what was said about "IT."
ReplyDeletehttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0e2kaQqxmQ0
You have mistaken me for Julie Lessman. She pipes things in. I shove them in.
ReplyDeleteHello again,
ReplyDeleteYou know, it's kind of a funny thing with journalism: I wrote that way in my day job, but when I wrote for my own enjoyment at night, I wanted to do something DIFFERENT. Which is probably why my first novel is rather off-the-wall and goofy. I wanted to break out of that clear-cut mold.
However, you asked if it is hard to write with emotion. My answer is yes and no. I WANT to write with more emotion, and I've been working on it. I discovered in my first draft that I had lots of scenes that had no real point in the overall story. I didn't know it when I initially wrote them, but I was getting to know my characters, feeling them out, deciding how they'd react to different situations. As I'm editing the third draft, I've cut many of those scenes and incorporated their emotions into other parts. I needed those extra scenes to get to know my characters on an emotional level,especially as someone who doesn't naturally write that way. Overall, though, a reader wouldn't be that interested in those extraneous scenes!
TRIVIA (MAYBE?) ANSWER: Not sure what year, but I know they were issued during WWII, probably after 1942, when the U.S. entered the war. It's one of my favorite eras to read/write about.
ReplyDeleteSilver penny -
ReplyDeleteWithout looking? I think it was 1943. I know it was during WW2, right?
Waving to Stephanie!
ReplyDeleteYour comment was right on! Often we have to write the extra scenes to better know or understand our characters. Smart you realized many of those scenes needed to be cut.
Didn't someone recently mention overwriting the first scene/chapter and then pulling out much of the info later? The first writing of the first chapter provides a get-to-know-your-character meeting on the page. Later, the author can dice and slice since, by then, she has a better understand of who her character really is.
Of course, all writing is done with clarity, as Janet pointed out so beautifully today.
ReplyDeleteOh, Walt, I'm snickering like a maniac and trotting in place. A time or two viewing that clip and no one would abide IT. :-)
ReplyDeleteJanet
Shoved or piped, they're delicious. Thanks Tina! Know you work in the kitchen with clean hands. :-)
ReplyDeleteJanet
Clean hands in the kitchen????
ReplyDeletePshaw.
Stephanie, you're not alone. Writers often write to discover what makes their characters tick. You are wise to see which scenes need cutting and which scenes need beefing up with a purpose. Love that you salvaged the emotional passages and have used them elsewhere.
ReplyDeleteJanet
Stephanie, you are right!! I'm impressed. I hadn't even heard of the silver penny before Friday. Copper was needed to supply the war effort. Anyone know the year? If you know when the war ended that narrows the possibilities.
ReplyDeleteJanet
JAN! you're right! 1943. The silver penny was minted just one year. I've never seen the coin but a friend says he has a couple so I will.
ReplyDeleteJanet
Janet, here's a secret: I learned about the silver penny when I was a kid, from reading the American Girl books. "Molly's" story takes place in 1944, and she mentions having a silver penny. Those books introduced me to a love of combining history and story at a young age.
ReplyDeleteRuthy, silly me. What was I thinking?
ReplyDeleteNote to Janet: microwave anything Ruthy serves in Seekerville
STEPHANIE! I love American Girl dolls. If I got one, I'd get Molly! The teacher who came up with the historical dolls sold the business for millions. I want to read those books! I'm a nut for history.
ReplyDeleteHere's a link to Molly.
http://store.americangirl.com/agshop/static/mollydoll.jsp
Janet
Hi Janet:
ReplyDeleteWhat a surprise to see your post on ‘crystal clear’ writing this morning! You covered both clarity and crystal clear clarity.
There is something magical about ‘crystal clear’ prose. The result is ‘music’ you can hear with your writer’s ear.
I enjoyed your crystal glass analogy. I use a second analogy as well. Consider two clear drinking glasses. One is all glass and the other is genuine crystal. If you ping the ‘glass’ cup with your finger, you’ll hear a ‘klunky’ sound that lasts about a second. If you do the same thing to the genuine crystal glass, you’ll hear a clear tone that may ring for up to a minute. This sound will have the resonant quality of a fine tuning fork.
(You can see this test done on YouTube here:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lf5TDX2EnOU )
When I read your first book, “Courting Miss Adelaide” I ‘heard’ that clarity. At the time I thought you would only carry this through for a few pages. I know how hard it is to do this because doing so is essential in advertising copywriting. I was amazed to find that the entire book was written in crystal clear prose. I don’t know what I enjoy more: your stories or reading your prose to see how you do it. I always try to get your new book the day it becomes available for the Kindle.
I believe that crystal clear prose goes well beyond simple clarity.
Here are some hallmarks of ‘crystal clear’ prose:
If prose is ‘crystal clear’, then
1. the fewest number of words will be used.
2. the most appropriate words will be used.
3. the most appropriate situation will be chosen to express those words.
4. the words used will only carry the meaning that the author intended.
5. the meaning of the words will ring true in the reader’s mind.
This is a very hard way to write. After each sentence the author should stop and ask: ‘can this sentence also mean something else?’ If yes, it needs to be fixed so it can only mean what the author intended.
Advertising copywriters must always be on guard against alternative meanings. A famous mistake is made in this ad:
“Hurry in today because these chairs won’t last long.”
It’s not just the words that create ‘crystal clear’ prose. It’s also the situation. The writer must decide which is the best way to present the communication that is intended.
Here’s an example:
The setup:
A large army force has the enemy’s fort surrounded. The Army general asks the fort commander to surrender.
Simple Clarity.
The fort commander gives a very clear, ten sentence, one hundred word, explanation as to why he will not surrender the fort. The General then returns to his camp.
Crystal Clear clarity
The General asks the fort commander to surrender. The fort commander takes a cigar out of his mouth and lights the fuse on a nearby cannon sending a cannon ball into General’s front line of men.
The commander’s decision here is crystal clear. No surrender -- now or ever. Since the General was under the white flag of truce to conduct the surender talks, any fort defender who is captured will be executed. It’s clear: this will be a fight to the death of the last defender.
Crystal clear writing is a way of thinking. It is not just the selection of the right words. I know crystal clear prose when I ‘hear’ it but that does not mean I can do it for very long. That’s a talent.
Janet you have that talent. I always await your next book with double anticipation.
Vince
BTW: the silver penny was minted in 1943 and I used to collect them as a kid. I had a whole cigar box full of them. I never saw a profit on any of them. However, I did spend years looking for a copper 1943 penny which I was told was worth a million dollars! I never found it but I did see a few pennies where someone had converted the 2 on a 1942 copper penny to look like a 3 on the 1943 penny. It looked just like a 1943 copper penny!!! Seeing one for the first time could almost cause a heart attack.
Vince, thanks so much for adding your two cents to this post. Loved your characteristics, analogies and examples of crystal clear prose.
ReplyDeleteI listened to the difference between glass and crystal on YouTube and heard that tuning fork quality of crystal. If we can make our words sing, our stories will remain with readers, even find a permanent place on their shelves.
I may have to pay you for your kind words...in silver pennies. :-)
Jan beat you to the answer. I learned about the coin at the Venice, a small family run restaurant. One wall is covered with plaques engraved with the names of diners born in 1943. They call themselves the Silver Penny Club. The owner is a member naturally.
I'm going to look through old copper pennies. If you thought you'd found a 1943, you must've come close to having a heart attack! Glad you survived. And share with us in Seekerville.
Janet
Karen, The Seekers toss out any title that pops into their minds. Some will be silly but often they contain a nugget to build on.
ReplyDeleteFun to share the April shelves with you!
Janet
When you run a damp finger around the rim of crystal, the glass will hum. Even sing. Good stories sing. Clarity is one reason a story sings.
ReplyDeleteReally? Wow! I had no clue. If I ever get the chance to do this, I WILL!
And I love this comparison. Janet, you are an amazing author AND a truly a cultured woman, but I knew that the moment I laid eyes on you! :)
Wonderful post on clarity, Janet! All very straightforward and clear. Your two cents are worth MUCH more than that.
ReplyDeleteI can't say that I write my fiction with clarity, but since I deal with a lot of finances with bookkeeping and when I was in purchasing, I had to be very clear about what I meant. Hopefully, this trait has spilled over into my fiction!
Kav, you make me laugh! Just change your story to werewolves, and you'll be all set!
ReplyDeleteAnd you'll sell MILLIONS of copies!!!
Oh, good post, Janet. One of my critters caught me being unclear yesterday. It was Debra Marvin in fact, and she said:
ReplyDelete"...although the storekeeper is the last referenced male, I was in Thomas's head enough that I felt it was THOMAS."
Good pick-up, Deb!
I'm also one of those who reads/edits emails/comments repeatedly to ensure there's no ambiguity. It usually works. Ha.
Pam, I knew you had a heart of gold when I first laid eyes on you. I was impressed with your long list of Golden Heart finals! What surprised me was your adeptness with numbers and purchasing metals. Trust me your eye for detail and need for clarity in your day job spilled over into your writing!
ReplyDeleteEverything we are and experience impacts our writing. Not craft so much as themes and voice.
Janet
Hi Anita Mae! Good for Debra for picking up on the need to clarify. Those pronouns are tricky.
ReplyDeleteNothing is foolproof, but anyone who writes everything they write with clarity gets a gold star.
Vince might give you a silver penny. :-)
Janet
Not sure I should wait until 7 p.m. to read through 115 comments next time...
ReplyDeleteNot only will I need to print out your post, Janet, but Vince's comment as well!
You wrote "Hmm, supportive spouses would make a good post." That would be a very interesting post to read, not to mention all the comments that would be written! My husband has always been very supportive of my desire to write, and we've been married 33 1/2 years. (I'm just not so supportive of myself!) He also does grocery shopping, laundry, and is the one who taught me how to change a diaper nearly 30 years ago (came from having 2 younger sisters and 33 foster brothers and sisters over the years)! I have a gem and tend to forget it... (Oops, the dreaded "it"...!)
Please toss my name into the hat for a copy of your book! Thank you. :)
Blessings,
Melanie
Hi Melanie! Bless your heart for plowing through all the comments! Your husband is a gem! You know I think some men have the heart of a servant and look for opportunities to help others. That's our husbands.
ReplyDeleteIT isn't bad when definable, which your IT is.
Thanks for your interest in my book!
Janet
This was such a great teaching post. I got much from it. I remember a creative writing instructor saying the ABC's of great writing were accuracy, brevity and clarity. Although I wonder about how well I learned the clarity part when I read my work. I agree if we get in the habit of writing everything clearly, it becomes an advantage in storytelling, too.
ReplyDeleteSince my TBR pile is so high, please don't put my name in for The Bride Wore Spurs. Thank you, Janet.
Excellent thoughts, Janet! Glad you took the risk and wrote this post!
ReplyDeleteJanet, great post, my friend! You hit on so many "blurry" points I identify in my writing, I appreciate your definitions of clarity.
ReplyDeleteI had to snicker when you mentioned sentence length. I tend to ramble as I formulate the direction of my scene. I've written sentences with 50+ words before. Try reading those out loud without coming up for air, LOL!
The best piece of advice you mentioned was the point about scene goals. If you don't know what your scene goal is, how can you write with clarity??
Great post, kiddo. I'm glad Vince gave you this particular atta-girl : )
Hi Pat Jeanne! Vince nailed your instructors points! Excellent. Have copied both what you and Vince said.
ReplyDeleteKeep on keeping on. Practice makes perfect!
Janet
Hi Eva Maria. I wasn't too worried. At least no one has tossed rotten tomatoes my way. Yet. LOL
ReplyDeleteJanet
Hi Audra! You have a wonderful way of expressing yourself and condensing a post that delights me!
ReplyDeleteFifty word sentences? Yikes, with my asthma I'd need an inhaler to read those aloud. Though one of my favorite historical writers could string a whole bunch of words together with clarity and emotion.
Janet
It does take me out of the story when things are unclear. Most informative thank you.
ReplyDeleteJanet,
ReplyDeleteThis was such a helpful article! Thank you for sharing!
Blessings!
Late to the party, but would love to win, Janet. Love the comments and the coffee, though it looks like the food I gone! Thanks
ReplyDeleteMANNNN did I need this!
ReplyDeleteMy edits are back and I'm working through. In between some nice compliments is a thread... woven into a rope that you've addressed here, Janet.
THANK YOU so much.
EXACTLY what I needed today! :)
So appreciate you!!!
Hi Mary P,
ReplyDeleteI can't scratch my head and turn the page. ;-)
Janet
Hi Edwina, glad you found the post helpful! Thanks!
ReplyDeleteJanet
Hi Marianne, been wondering if you received the copy of The Bride Wore Spurs I sent you.
ReplyDeleteJanet
Hi KC, Don't you love God's timing? Hope the post helps with those edits.
ReplyDeleteJanet